Consumer Auto Repair Consultants
Consumer Auto Repair
Consultants

Independent advice on your repair bill

Before you approve that repair, get a second opinion on the price.

Dealers and repair shops have consultants who help them maximize every repair order. You deserve someone in your corner too. Send us your estimate and a fixed operations professional will tell you if it's fair, what to question, and where you can save.

$50 estimate reviews and $35 phone consultations. We don't work for any dealer or shop, and we don't take referral fees.

REPAIR ESTIMATE
2019 SUV · 3.5L V6 · 94,210 mi
Sample review
Line / OpHrsAmount
Replace water pump & thermostatBilled 4.8 hr. Labor guide is 3.6 hr.4.8$1,032.00
Water pump, OEMPrice in line with OEM list—$389.50
Coolant system flushOverlaps the pump job. Ask to remove it.1.0$215.00
Fuel induction serviceNot in manufacturer maintenance schedule0.8$189.95
Shop supplies—$68.00
Quoted $1,894.45 Fair target ≈ $1,320

Why this exists

The shop knows the numbers. Most customers don't.

You're asked to decide on the spot

The car is on the lift, a service advisor is waiting, and a $3,000 approval feels urgent. That's the worst time to figure out whether the price is right.

Estimates are hard to read

Labor hours, op codes, parts markup, add-on services and shop fees all look the same on paper. Small padding on each line adds up fast on a big repair.

Nobody is advising you

Dealers and independent shops pay industry consultants to grow profit per repair order. Until now, consumers had no equivalent.

Before you post that photo

You wouldn't get legal advice from a comment thread. Don't get repair advice there either.

When you have a legal problem, you call a lawyer. You don't post it on Reddit and go with the most upvoted reply. A repair that costs thousands deserves the same care.

Forums, Facebook groups and short videos can be a good place to learn. But the people answering:

  • Haven't seen your estimate. They're reacting to a few sentences and a photo, not the full repair order.
  • Don't know your market. Labor rates and parts prices vary widely by region and by shop.
  • Aren't accountable. Anyone can claim to be a mechanic, and nobody stands behind the answer.
  • Often disagree. Ten replies can give you ten answers, and you're left to guess which one is right.

We read the actual paperwork, know how dealer and independent shop pricing works from the inside, and give you one clear answer you can act on.

How it works

From estimate to decision in four steps

You send what the shop gave you. We review it line by line and tell you what to do next.

STEP 1

Send your estimate

Upload a photo or PDF of the estimate and answer a few questions about your vehicle and the repair.

About 5 minutes
STEP 2

We review every line

We check labor hours against industry guides, parts pricing against list, and whether each recommended service is actually needed now.

Same business day
STEP 3

Get a clear answer

You get a written review: what's fair, what to question, a target price, and the exact words to use with your service advisor.

Written + phone option
STEP 4

Decide with confidence

Approve, negotiate, defer what can wait, or take it elsewhere. If you want another quote, we'll point you to options in your area.

You stay in control

We review pricing and repair recommendations based on the information you provide. We don't physically inspect your vehicle, so we can't confirm a diagnosis. When the diagnosis itself is in doubt, we'll tell you and suggest how to get it verified.

What we review

What a fixed ops professional looks for

Labor time

Billed hours compared with published labor guides, including overlap when two jobs share the same teardown.

Parts pricing

OEM vs. aftermarket, markup over list, and whether a quality alternative fits your budget and how long you plan to keep the car.

Necessary now, later, or never

Which items are safety-critical, which can wait, and which upsells aren't in your manufacturer's maintenance schedule.

Warranty, recalls and goodwill

Open recalls, technical service bulletins, extended coverage, and when to ask the manufacturer for goodwill assistance on an out-of-warranty failure.

Extended warranty claims

Help understanding a service contract denial and what documentation to ask the shop for.

Fees and fine print

Diagnostic charges, shop supplies, environmental fees, and whether a teardown fee applies if you decline the work.

What you walk away with

A plan, not just an opinion

A fair price range

A target number for the repair, with the reasoning behind it, so you know when a quote is reasonable.

Talking points for the shop

Specific, polite questions to ask your service advisor that get line items adjusted without a fight.

Your next options

When it makes sense, guidance on getting a second quote and the kinds of shops best suited to your repair.

Pricing

Two ways to get help. Flat prices.

On a repair that costs thousands, finding one padded labor line or one unnecessary service can cover the fee many times over.

Estimate review

$50 per repair order

You have an estimate or bill and want to know if it's fair.

  • Line-by-line review of labor, parts and fees
  • A fair target price for the repair
  • What's needed now and what can wait
  • Warranty, recall and goodwill check
  • Talking points for your service advisor
  • Side-by-side comparison if you have multiple estimates
Upload my estimate

Repair consultation

$35 per 30-minute call

No estimate yet? Talk it through with someone who doesn't work for the shop.

  • A 30-minute phone call with a fixed ops professional
  • Help understanding a symptom, warning light or diagnosis
  • Dealer vs. independent shop: which fits this repair
  • Whether the car is worth fixing
  • What to ask before you hand over the keys
  • Upload photos or documents ahead of the call if you have them
Book a call

What counts as one repair order?

One repair on one vehicle, including every line item. If you have estimates from several shops for that same repair, send them all. We'll compare them side by side for the same $50.

Does it matter how big the repair is?

No. The review fee is the same for a $600 brake job or an $8,000 engine replacement.

Which one should I choose?

If a shop has given you a written estimate or bill, choose the estimate review. If you're still figuring out what's wrong or where to take the car, book a consultation.

Form not loading? Open it in a new tab.